DC Comics’ Legends #6

The sixth and final chapter of this epic saga (I say this perhaps with only a touch of irony. A smidge. A scoch) begins with Darkseid ready to deliver an old school, classic monologue about how awesome he and his plan are.

But lo! The Phantom Stranger is tere to harsh Darkseid’s mellow, because that’s what heroes do. Even if the Stranger can’t intervene directly, the least he can do is rain on Darkseid’s Apokoliptic parade.

The article continues after these advertisements...

What follows is a page and a half of exposition for people who didn’t bother to pick up the previous five issues, or who have such short memories that they forgot what happened a bare month ago. The Stranger is unimpressed with Darkseid’s expository skills, however, and says his plan is boned. Because even now as we turn the page, we find Glorious Gordon Godfrey on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial, facing off against Doctor Fate’s super posse. Godfrey starts to get the crowd good and fired up, but the heroes aren’t paying a lot of attention as a newcomer arrives on the scene.

Doctor Fate is surprised at the Martian Manhunter showing up, because he wasn’t invited. Hmph, racist much, Dr. F? But Batman doesn’t discriminate, and he says J’onn J’onzz is welcome. I expect no less from a guy who opens his house to orphans. Superman asks if the rest of the Justice League is coming, and the Manhunter lays down a bombshell: the League no longer exists. Judging by the quality of the Justice League of America title I was buying at the time, that statement is a couple of years late.

Godfrey gets tired of being ignored and sends in the Warhounds to attack. This is followed by a couple of pages of really epic fighting. Say what you will about Byrne’s real and/or imagined personal shortcomings; the man can craft some stellar action sequences. Fate uses his power to cause Warhound pilots to phase out of their metallic dogs, Supes scraps one with a single blow, and Batman jumps on board another, gets inside, and knocks out two pilots with one punch. Godfrey just now wakes up to the fact that the Warhounds kind of suck, and he summons a hoard of parademons. Now, I get the fact that the crowd is mind controlled, but you’d think maybe—juuust maybe—they might wake up to the fact that this propagandist is more than he seems when he can conjure up legions of winged demons. But nope, the crowd is still convinced somehow that superheroes are bad. While the heroes go to fight the new threat, Fate tries to talk some sense into the crowd, but Godfrey takes advantage of the situation.

There’s this thing called a “chin strap”. Maybe you’ve heard of it, Dr. Fate? It helps to prevent a helmet from coming off your head. Kent Nelson, now back in the control, realizes the crowd is about to… wait, one of these people has a torch. A goddamn torch! What is this, Bride of Frankenstein? Are these people going to storm a castle later on? Kent doesn’t stick around to ask and he exposits via thought balloons that he still has enough Fate Juice for flight and super-strength, which I actually think I remember from the old All-Star Squadron comics.

Kent flies off to get the helmet while a grinnin’ Godfrey heads off to check in on his prisoner. Poor Captain Boomerang is being guarded by some Warhounds, and Godfrey starts pumping the man for information. So Boomerang decides he’s got a lot to say, which could prove to be bad for his health, because somebody is watching.

But before Deadshot can give Digger’s skull a new orifice (or two, depending on the caliber of that rifle. Christ, that thing looks like it could take down aircraft!), Col. Flag stops the shot and says they’re not killing anybody unless absolutely necessary. He has Enchantress turn the Warhounds into what looks like silly putty, and sics Bronze Tiger on Godfrey. Tiger chases the Glorious One down an alleyway, but Godfrey whacks his pursuer with the mind control mojo.

Meanwhile, Flag collects Boomerang, but not before telling the man he’s on the Suicide Squad, perhaps permanently, and then laying him out with a punch. Elsewhere, the heroes not taking on the parademons are beating the crap out of Godfrey’s foot soldiers. Guy Gardner shows that he’s not all mouth and is crushing Warhounds left and right (and I’m sure the people inside are fine. Really). Then the gang gets a shocking assist.

Yeah! Cue ’70s theme music!

Guy is typically Guy, which means he’s about as smooth as sandpaper when he introduces himself to the newcomer… Wait, newcomer? Am I reading this right? Guy doesn’t know who Wonder Woman is? Are they implying Diana, Princess of Themyscira, has just recently entered into the DC Universe? Then who the hell helped found the Justice League? You know, that classic story where seven heroes fought seven aliens? I mean yeah, okay, I was buying Wonder Woman at the time, and the storyline there was that she just showed up in “Man’s World”, but I kind of figured it was just an extended origin story. Did nobody think this through? I’m not just talking about the Justice League problem. What about Wonder Girl?

It’s like Robin predating Batman, for God’s sake! Wonder Girl’s origin is directly tied in with Wonder Woman’s; there is no separation! This was the principal problem with the DC reboot, in that it was soft; some comics were affected, others not so much. Teen Titans was largely untouched, because it was still one of DC’s biggest sellers at the time, and they didn’t want to mess with it. This short-term decision would have long lasting repercussions and pretty much wreck Donna Troy as a character, who to this day still hasn’t recovered.

But back to Legends. Bad guys attack the White House and blow a hole in the side of the Oval Office. I guess the presidential residence is made from the same stuff as the X-Men Mansion, because that wall went down easy. The terrorists storm the Oval Office, but Ronald Reagan, veteran of numerous war films and co-star to a chimpanzee, is not afraid.

Yeah, Reagan’s tough like gristle. He must have coated his body in the same stuff he uses in his hair. But lo an behold, another Ronald Reagan enters the room! It turns out the Ronnie that got shot was the Martian Manhunter. Reagan shakes the illegal immigrant’s hand (although he was probably granted amnesty due to the 1986 Immigration Reform Act), and as J’onn flies off, Reagan finally pulls his pruney skull out of his wrinkled butt and rescinds the no-heroes executive order.

Elsewhere, Superman and Captain Marvel are cleaning house overhead, knockin’ parademons around, while dirtside, other heroes are smacking around rioters.

Blue Beetle asks how Black Canary’s doing, and she pretty much bites his head off, telling him she’s an “old hand” at this. Hey, for all he knows, you’re a new Black Canary; if I was him, I couldn’t imagine the original wearing that costume. I mean, seriously, the only person who could rock a headband in the ’80s was Bruce Springsteen. The heroes regroup and circle the wagons, and Godfrey orders a final assault that he’s sure will probably cause at least a few civilian casualties and make the heroes look even worse. Darkseid and the Phantom Stranger look on as things are about to get ugly, when suddenly…

“No! Stop!! You mustn’t do this!”? Man, I really think writers Ostrander and Wein needed to get some of this dialogue proofread by some kids, because as well-spoken as I was when I was ten, at no time would I have ever used the word “mustn’t”. It turns out Robin got these kids here… somehow… and hey, it turns out Lisa didn’t die in that alley! Good for her! She tries to talk sense into her dad, but Godfrey ain’t having it. He uses a play I’m sure he borrowed from Granny Goodness’ book on how to raise kids.

And just like that, the crowd turns on Godfrey. Using giant robot dog tanks? That’s okay. Calling for the overthrow of the United States government? Great! Summoning demons, it’s all good. Slapping a kid? Now you’ve gone too far. Godfrey realizes he screwed up big time, and he reaches into his overcoat to pull out Fate’s helmet.

Apparently, when it comes to Nabu helmets, one size does not fit all. The helmet cooks Godfrey’s brains, which allows Bronze Tiger to break free of his control and slip away before people start asking who the hell the guy in the tiger mask is. The Joe Normals ask the heroes for forgiveness, and Supes is all about letting bygones be bygones, but Guy is super pissed and says the people must have always feared them deep down. But Captain Marvel—my favorite one—channels some Solomon wisdom and points out it’s their job to stand apart from the crowd, and that’ll always cause a little mistrust. If Guy wants hero worship, then he’s in the wrong place.

Wonder Woman backs up Marvel, and Doctor Fate points out that hey, as long as the gang’s all here, maybe they might want to reform the Justice League? Bats, J’onn, Marvel, Black Canary and Blue Beetle are all on board, while Guy says he’ll think about it. The Flash says his life’s too much of a mess right now, and Changeling’s already a Teen Titan, and Superman says “no” and Wonder Woman exits, leaving us with the new line-up.

Which I gotta say is a helluva lot better than Justice League Detroit. But y’know, in retrospect, it would’ve been nice if Vixen had been included. Of all the new Justice League Detroit characters, she was the only one with any staying power. Unfortunately, we wouldn’t see her again until a brief guest appearance in Animal Man, followed by a sustained run in Suicide Squad.

Elsewhere, Darkseid says it was a good plan, and it would have worked if it hadn’t been for those pesky kids! We close out with the Phantom Stranger talking about what constitutes a legend, while our heroes strike a pose.

So, overall, was Legends any good? Yes and no. The plot was solid and the art top-notch, and it gave us Amanda Waller and what would later be known as the Suicide Squad. Any story that plants an enduring, positive mark like that cannot in any way, shape, or form be called bad.

But… it could have been better. Legends was meant to accomplish some goals, among them to introduce Waller and Task Force X, as well as lay the groundwork for the new Justice League. It was also meant to give readers a glimpse at the DC Universe’s new status quo, showing how alternate Earth characters like Doctor Fate and Captain Marvel now co-existed in the same world as other established heroes, with everyone acting like it had always been that way. But I think the execution was a little, well, sloppy. How much time passes in the comic, exactly? Sometimes it feels like weeks, other times it feels like a weekend. It’s possible that the editors at Marvel might have taken a look at this series when the concept for Civil War was being worked out, because months before that comic’s release, there had been hints of its coming in various storylines throughout the Marvel Universe. Legends could have done with a few months’ delay, with DC writers hinting at Glorious Godfrey’s rising popularity in different titles, culminating in his explosive surge in prominence. And okay, let’s be fair here; while I ragged on the Wonder Girl/Wonder Woman issue, that wasn’t the fault of this series.

I give the series overall a strong B, where we had some bad outweighed by the good, and I’m not at all ashamed to have it residing in my collection.

Tag: DC Legends

You may also like...

  • GreenLuthor

    B? Yeah, that sounds about right. I liked Legends well enough, but… yeah, there were some problems that become much more noticeable on rereading them all at once. (Like pinning down where things are happening. Brimstone shows up in New York City, but is suddenly in South Dakota? Did he walk there, without anyone trying to stop him? Boomerang is caught by Godfrey’s rioters in New York, but brought to him in Metropolis, and then Godfrey brings him to Washington DC? Robin is in a Gotham City hospital, but also gets himself to DC? (Though that’s also a problem with DC not pinning down where some of their fictional cities are actually located, but it’s hard to imagine Gotham and Metropolis both being within easy walking distance of both New York and DC…))

    “Say what you will about Byrne’s real and/or imagined personal shortcomings; the man can craft some stellar action sequences.” True. From everything I’ve heard, he’s not someone I’d want to meet in person, but… he is one of the best writers and artists comics have ever had. (At least when he’s not doing self-indulgent nonsense like using the bottom quarter of every page of an issue to give a running recap of the series to date. I mean, it was still well-drawn but… why????)

    “Blue Beetle asks how Black Canary’s doing, and she pretty much bites his head off, telling him she’s an ‘old hand’ at this. Hey, for all he knows, you’re a new Black Canary; if I was him, I couldn’t imagine the original wearing that costume.” Heck, even in the post-Crisis continuity, she wasn’t the original Black Canary, her mother was. (Black Canary was the lucky winner of a messed-up retconned history even before Crisis.)

    Yeah, the Wonder Woman reboot really messed up Donna Troy. Along with Hawkman (friggin’ Hawkman?), she was probably the biggest victim of DC’s reboots. (Legion of Super-Heroes managed to salvage themselves as best they could, until they got a full reboot later. And speaking of Legion, it sure was nice of Legends to feature Cosmic Boy on the cover of the first issue, since he was so important to the series… ) (Yeah, I know about the mini-series. He still kinda seems to up and disappear in Legends #2.)

    I suppose the name “G. Gordon Godfrey” is interesting, being what would probably have to be a reference to G. Gordon Liddy (that name can’t be a coincidence, right?). Interesting because Godfrey was already based on another real-world person, televangelist Billy Graham. (What was Jack Kirby’s opinion on Graham? Well, he named a character based on him “God-free”, so… yeah. That one’s not a coincidence.)

    Anyhoo… Legends had its flaws, but DC’s next big crossover event was Millennium, so… at least Legends has that going for it…

  • Kradeiz

    “This was the principal problem with the DC reboot, in that it was soft; some comics were affected, others not so much.”

    And 25 years later DC made this mistake again with the New 52. If you’re gonna reboot your universe to clean up continuity and draw in new readers, great, but you have to commit to it. Doing it halfway just makes it confusing for everybody.

    • Xander

      Yeah, I remember seeing the cover to Green Lantern #1 with Sinestro on the cover and was actually a little bit interested. I mean, to take it back to before Hal Jordan to when Sinestro was still a hero was interesting idea. I thought I might give DC comics a chance again.

      When I actually read the comic and it was a direct continuation of the Skittle Lantern Wars that I hated? I didn’t pick up any more New 52 titles. Given the quality of the ones I read through the library? I’m glad I saved my money.

  • coldmaster613

    You know what, I’m on Guy’s side on this one. The civilians may have been under an influence, but they were still too quick to believe in the worst. They were so deep into the “Let’s hate all Super-Heroes, despite the countless times they’ve saved the world” bandwagon, that they almost beat up a teen to death because he was wearing a costume. Hell, I’m glad that someone, anyone was willing to call them out on their quickness to hate. Overall the series had an interesting idea. What if the DC universe hated and feared the heroes, just like the X-men? However, it was a plan created by a super villain so that when our heroes are driven out, the villain would take over. A part of me wished that Darkseid had won so that he can point out how easy it was for him to take over the world because the people were ungrateful assholes towards the superheroes.

    • Greenhornet

      To see a GOOD depiction of heroes feared and hated, you would have to go back to around 1939 when they were “costumed vigilantes” that took their cue from the pulp stories. That could be done today, but I don’t think today’s reader would get it. Society has changed too much. Even the “brilliant amateur detective” is long gone.

    • Thomas Stockel

      This is why I liked Guy in this series, because he did not march in lock step with other heroes. He was abrasive and could have been the Justice League’s Wolverine in that regard.

      But f-ing Giffen and Demattes spoiled things. Oh, I won’t lie, I bought the entire Bwahahahaha era so I was part of the problem, but I loved(!) Kevin Maguire’s art. Forgive me, I was young, I was weak. It wasn’t until later when I read those comics that I realized how unfunny they largely are.

      • Chefe O’Hara

        I think Giffen/DeMatteis’ League was the only thing that could be done at that time. A seriously written JL full of second-stringers had been already tried and the result was the almost universally hated JL Detroit.

        So, there were only two options: either a full comeback to glory with cosmic stories starring the house’s biggest stars, or a new way to write the second-stringers. Since the “big guns” weren’t available, the former wasn’t an option. So, they had to think about what kind of stories they could tell about that bunch. And, seriously, would you like to read, at that time, about the interpersonal conflicts and suffering souls of Blue Beetle, Booster Gold, Black Canary and Fire?

        Of course, it could have worked. Giffen himself succeded on that as Paul Levitz’s co-plotter at the “Legion of Super-Heroes” (although these characters, while not heavvyweights themselves, had already a lot of emotional baggage among readers). Marv Wolfman and George Pérez also did that with The New Teen Titans (and even they had faced a lot of readers’ opposition at the beggining). The same can’t be said, however, of Dan Jurgens’ own Teen Titans, full of unknown faces.

        So, I don’t think Keith and J.M. were wrong on going the humor way. And it was, if you can forgive the cliché, a fresh breeze in the forest of Claremont/Moore/Miller wannabes, each and all wanting to be grimmier and grittier than what had been done before, and only looking like an involuntary “The Naked Gun”.

        (By the way, I believe the seeds of the Giffen-League Guy were planted here, in “Legends”. He was kind of a joke-telling jerk in this story, and the writer might’ve thought that was a nice starting point to an otherwise one-dimensional character. And I’ve to agree with him: if written seriously, he would just be labelled as a “poor man’s Wolverine, like so many “loose cannons” who came after him.)

        (And he still was a loose cannon, order-refusing rebel, but while sometimes his impulsive actions earned him victory, more often than not he had to face the negative consequences of them.)

  • Michael Weyer

    So they redid JLA history to basically replace Black Canary into Wonder Woman’s spot (including the terrific JLA Year One series) and bending over backwards to fit her into current history.

    Which as you noted, turned Donna Troy’s history into a nightmare that can rival Hawkman in terms of confusing reboots.

    And in 2005, DC redoes history so Diana is a founder of the League after all.

    • Thomas Stockel

      Yup. And Donna Troy got boned again when they put the other Wonder Girl in Teen Titans. I honestly can’t remember the other Wonder Girl’s name.

      I don’t know, maybe they were going to introduce Donna as a member of an iteration of the Teen Titans that was in existence in the past because that is what was implied, that there were earlier Teen Titans teams. But then that was re-written when the TT tpb was released, which shows just how hastily the whole New 52 reboot was executed.

      But from what I heard it was not DC editors’ fault. A Time Warner suit insisted on the changes and if you look at Geoff Johns Flashpoint Paradox series and it’s tie-ins it looks like there were some long term plans in mind; the New 52 was not in the cards at that point

      • Xander

        Her name was Cassie Sandsmark. She was great in Young Justice, but then someone wanted to reboot Teen Titans, so that book was canceled, and most of Young Justice went over to the Titans. Because reasons.

  • Michael Weyer

    Given all the crap Boomerang would end up putting him and the Squad through, I’m sure Flag wished later he’d have just let Deadshot shoot the jerk.

    • Xander

      One of the best Suicide Squad stories in the ’90s was in the pages of the Superboy comic. Deadshot decides that Boomerang’s sold out the Squad one too many times and shoots him in each hand.