TV Episode Reviews & Recaps
Sort By:
[Popular Now]
[Date Posted]
[Series Title]
[Original Airdate]
Agonizer (Everything Else)
Sort By:
[Popular Now]
[Date Posted]
TV Episode Reviews & Recaps
Sort By:
[Popular Now]
[Date Posted]
[Series Title]
[Original Airdate]
Agonizer (Everything Else)
Sort By:
[Popular Now]
[Date Posted]
Blood Splattered Cinema
Hosted by: Horror Guru
The Horror Guru reviews the bloodiest, wildest, and weirdest horror that cinema has to offer!
Cartoon Palooza
Hosted by: Joey Tedesco
A satirical review show where a guy from Jersey watches and criticizes cartoons, including everything from comic books to animated movies. Whatever it is, Joey will either tell you to run out and see it... or fughetabouit!
The Count Jackula Show
Hosted by: Count Jackula
There are vampires, and there are men from outer space, but there is only one vampire from outer space! Join Count Jackula from the Planet Drakula as he explains the ins and outs of horror, from the mythic to the modern. Blood, off-color humor, and an obsession with Elvira are in store for you!
The Examined Life (of Gaming)
Hosted by: Roland Thompson
Just when video games were getting good, the late '90s and early '00s came along. The Examined Life (of Gaming) dares to delve into the good, the bad, and the value-priced games of this dark period, and sometimes we find something worth playing!
The Film Renegado
Hosted by: Film Renegado
Coming to you from south of the border, it's the Film Renegado! A civil engineer with a cinephile complex, the Film Renegado uses movies made in Mexico or by Mexican directors to share bits from his country's culture, past and present. You will both learn and be entertained! How cool is that?
Friday Night Fright Flicks
Hosted by: Count Jackula & Horror Guru
Welcome, fright knights, to Friday Night Fright Flicks! Join your hosts Count Jackula and the Horror Guru as they stumble their way through current horror releases, letting you know which ones are worth the price of admission.
Good Bad Flicks
Hosted by: Cecil Trachenburg
Good Bad Flicks is a show not only dedicated to rare movies, but also forgotten classics and misunderstood box office bombs. Your host Cecil takes you through each movie, discussing the promotional materials, and taking a look at what went on behind the scenes. With a healthy dose of Irish sarcasm, he throws a few jabs at even his most cherished favorites.
The Graphic Novel Picture Show
Hosted by: Sybil Pandemic
Your host Solkir presents The Graphic Novel Picture Show, a retrospective of the history of comic book movies!
The Movie Skewer
Hosted by: Team Agony Booth
From the makers of the Agony Booth™ comes The Movie Skewer, where terrible movies are roasted over an open flame for your enjoyment. Watch the very first online review/recap series that’s too much for one host to handle!
Mr. Mendo's Hack Attack
Hosted by: Michael A. Novelli
Need a healthy dose of cynicism from a guy whose face you can barely see? Then Mr. Mendo’s your man! Whether a movie suffers from Hype Backlash, Intellectual Dishonesty, or is just Complete Shit, Mr. Mendo is there. Mr. Mendo wasn‘t raised in this country, so he takes nothing for granted: if something ain‘t right, he’ll nose it out. So join him as he takes on Oscar winners and legendary flops alike in front of a blanket suspended between his couch and recliner!
Stuff You Like
Hosted by: Sursum Ursa
Stuff You Like is an original show where redhead Sursum Ursa waxes enthusiastic about movies, TV shows, and anything else that comes to mind! Expect singing, snarky subtitles, random pictures she finds on the internet, and lots of fangirling!
Terror Obscura
Hosted by: Fear Fan
Terror Obscura is a show dedicated to exploring the best and worst horror films ever made. While some shows are content to just mock bad films, this one isn't afraid to take even the most sacred of cows to the slaughterhouse. If you like horror, humor, or if you're just looking to find some titles you might want to rent, Terror Obscura is the show for you!
Tom's Retrophilia
Hosted by: Thomas Stockel
Is he a connoisseur of vintage media, or just a bitter old man trapped in the past?  Either way, tune in and watch Tom take a look at the movies and television shows from a time when he was actually in the target audience!
The Unusual Suspect
Hosted by: Unusual Suspect
The Unusual Suspect reviews popular movies, and tears 'em apart! They may be good, but no movie is perfect, and there's always things you may have overlooked and hadn't thought about. So join the Suspect as he exploits and ridicules the films you know and love. Just don't kill him for it!
What We Had to Watch
Hosted by: Il Neige
Il Neige is a smart-ass with a love-hate relationship with movies from the new millennium. Sure, reviews can be fun or cathartic, but there's also the risk of the occasional Twi-hard invasion or fireball to the face! ...That's how these things usually go, right? So join Il Neige as he braves the cinematic dangers that lie just beyond the fourth wall to critique the best and worst of 21st century filmmaking!
Click to see all our shows!
the agony booth

The Cast of Characters:
Edward Speleers as EragonEragon (Edward Speleers). Callow, young, blonde-headed farm boy destined to save the world from the evil Empire by joining an ancient and long-dead order of peacekeepers. No, I'm not talking about Luke Skywalker. I'm talking about the stupidest, most self-centred hero in the history of storytelling—in fact, the very definition of a Gary Stu.
Rachael Weisz as SaphiraSaphira (Rachael Weisz). The wimpiest dragon ever. No personality, no opinions, no character arc. Basically, a big, computer-generated plot device. Despite being the last of an ancient and powerful race, Saphira chooses to partner with the most idiotic rider imaginable, instead of just eating him like any self-respecting dragon would do.
Jeremy Irons as BromBrom (Jeremy Irons). A former member of an ancient order of peacekeepers, long ago wiped out by traitors. Now living in secret in a backwater community. Plays mentor to our rash hero while treating him like dirt. Bzzt! Sorry, "Obi-Wan Kenobi" is incorrect. Two guesses what happens to Brom halfway into the movie.
Garrett Hedlund as MurtaghMurtagh (Garrett Hedlund). The only vaguely likeable character in the entire movie, and cooler than our "hero" to the point that you start wondering why he's not the main character. He's better looking, twice as intelligent, and kicks a hundred times more ass than Eragon. Plus, he's clearly aware that he's in a stupid movie, making him that much more sympathetic.
Sienna Guillory as AryaArya (Sienna Guillory). The inevitable love interest. No reason to be in the story at all, except to assure everyone that our hero isn't gay. (Not that it put off the slashfic writers.) Oh, and she's meant to be an elf. You're just going to have to take my word on that.
Robert Carlyle as DurzaDurza (Robert Carlyle). The Evil King's right-hand man. No, not Darth Vader. Durza is supposedly a sorcerer who was taken over by evil spirits and turned into a supernatural being called a "Shade". Wants to kill Eragon very badly, but for some reason can't be bothered to go out and do it himself.
John Malkovich as King GalbatorixKing Galbatorix (John Malkovich). Some bald guy who appears in approximately three scenes in the entire movie, and has no impact on the plot. Apparently, it's very important that someone kill him, but I really can't tell why. Also, he's the only King ever to rule an Empire. Try and figure that one out if you can.

Where has all the originality gone?

I'm not just talking about what's going on in Hollywood right now, with the slew of remakes and adaptations currently emerging en masse. I'm not just talking about the publication of Eragon, a book that's essentially an extended Star Wars/Lord of the Rings/Dragonriders of Pern crossover fanfiction starring a Gary Stu.

I'm talking about the latest step that the moviemaking world has taken, by making an adaptation of a book that's basically Star Wars with the names changed to faux-LotR, conveniently encapsulating both of the current hot trends in filmmaking. Except that in this case, the remake was made without permission, thus saving the expense of paying George Lucas or Tolkien's estate for the rights. I can't help but be impressed.

I suppose it was pretty much inevitable that Eragon would get a movie adaptation. At the moment, Hollywood will adapt anything that counts as a bestseller (and since the book was written by a 19-year-old kid—and published by his parents, incidentally—it became a bestseller pretty quickly regardless of its quality). And of course, fantasy is very much "in" at the moment.

The rights to Eragon (and, it's rumoured, the sequels—hey, it's not fantasy unless it's a trilogy) were sold to Fox very early on, and the movie went into production a couple of years ago. Expectations were quite high—even among people who were unimpressed by the book. I wasn't a fan, but I had very high hopes for the movie. If the plot and characters were re-imagined by someone older and more experienced than their original author, I reasoned, they could actually make for an exciting movie.

The article continues after this advertisement...

As details began to emerge and many differences between book and film showed up, I was encouraged (of course, most of the fans weren't). When it was revealed that four high-class actors had signed up—Jeremy Irons, John Malkovich, Djimon Hounsou and Robert Carlyle—along with several others who were certainly good at their craft—Rachael Weisz, Garrett Hedlund and Sienna Guillory—it seemed we were at least in for some decent performances. And Industrial Light and Magic were doing the special effects. So it was all very promising, no?

Well, not quite. There were a few warning signs. One of them was the decision to cast an unknown in the title role. It's not a guarantee of failure—after all, it worked for Harry Potter and Superman Returns. But there were other, more worrying signs.

There was the director, Stefen Fangmeier, a special effects supervisor whose directing experience was limited to second-unit work on Dreamcatcher and Galaxy Quest. Then there was the screenwriter, Peter Buchman, who had only one previous script to his name: Jurassic Park III. Yeahhhh. That's some real skill and experience right there, huh? A director who'd never directed before (although his special effects résumé is impressive), and a screenwriter who wrote an extremely stupid movie about dinosaurs failing to kill people.

Still, I continued to rationalize that this didn't mean they would sink the movie. After all, Fangmeier had worked on dozens of movie sets and must have known something about directing. And maybe Buchman just hadn't had the chance to flex his screenwriting muscles and show us what he could really do (I keep saying the same thing about Lindsay Lohan's acting, but no one seems to agree with me).

And then came the final warning sign: the trailer was delayed. Over and over again. It was supposed to be attached to Superman Returns. Then it was All the King's Men. Then it was Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest. Every single time, they changed their minds at the last minute. On several occasions, the trailer was supposed to become available on the Internet within a few days, but then Fox would pull it at the last minute, to the eternal frustration of fans.

And the movie itself had its release date suddenly changed several times without notice, mere months before it was due to arrive in cinemas. Something was up. Fox's excuse was that they weren't happy with the CGI yet, and wanted to be completely sure it was up to snuff (interestingly enough, exactly the same excuse was used when the poorly-received Ghost Rider was delayed).

Balderdash. The early trailers for King Kong were released well before the CG was finished. They made due with some temporary models, and got plenty of publicity while they were still finishing the movie, and ending up doing some pretty good business.

No, it was pretty easy to tell what was really going on: Fox had test-screened the thing and they weren't happy with it. Something was going on behind the scenes. Most likely, the footage was being given a very rough recut by some desperate editor trying to salvage a decent movie out of it.

Either way, it didn't work. The movie arrived in cinemas after a very half-hearted ad campaign, and in spite of the ready-made audience in the form of fans of the book, it bombed spectacularly.

The negative reviews came thick and fast, and before I'd read more than a handful of them, I already knew the movie was dead on arrival. It made a fair wad of cash—it had a budget of about $100 million, and earned approximately $163 million worldwide—but in no way was it a smashing success. And even if it wasn't a complete financial catastrophe, it was definitely an outright critical failure. I hadn't seen movie reviews that vicious since Battlefield Earth. And here's the thing—even fans of the book hated it. The anti-fans, of course, had a field day.

The Critics Rave about Eragon!

"Stefen Fangmeier establishes himself as the Uwe Boll of family-friendly fantasy."
John Beifuss, Commercial Appeal

"Why has 20th Century Fox released this embarrassment—whose quality would be dubious for a direct-to-video release—into theatres?"
James Berardinelli, ReelViews

"More than a Star Wars rip-off... The only thing missing here is a Chewbacca."
Kevin Carr, 7M Pictures

"The film's few moments of hilarity are no less welcome for being completely unintended..."
Jeannette Catsoulis, New York Times

"Fears that Fangmeier's debut would be the sequel to Dragonheart nobody wanted prove unwarranted. It's the sequel to BloodRayne that nobody wanted."
Walter Chaw, Film Freak Central

"For those who love the fantasy genre known as sword and sorcery—and I count myself in their number—sitting through the movie version of Eragon will suck the will to live right out of you."
Chauncey Mabe, South Florida Sun-Sentinel

"George Lucas should sue their sorry plagiarist asses..."
James O'Ehley, Sci-Fi Movie Page

"If you took all the dragon-centred movies ever made, and counted the good ones on your fingers, I bet you'd still have enough fingers left over to flip off Eragon as you walked laughing from the theatre."
Eric D. Snider,

"Laughably bad, mind-bogglingly derivative, and easily one of the worst movies of the year."
Pete Vonder Haar, Film Threat

Of course, seeing as how I'm an intelligent, independent thinker, as well as a complete moron, I went to see the movie anyway.

Amazingly enough, I discovered that when you adapt a plagiaristic, shallow, and poorly-written book, you end up with a plagiaristic, shallow, and poorly-made movie. So let us begin our journey into Alagaësia, land of teleporting horses, dragons with feathers, and peasants who wear leather vests. I hope you've got a good health insurance policy. Because this is going to hurt.

Latest Comments

Top Trackbacks (Pages linking to this recap)
(3556 hits)
(2656 hits)
(1966 hits)
(1757 hits)
(1506 hits)
(1250 hits)
(1223 hits)
(730 hits)
(375 hits)
(327 hits)

Popular Right Now

Posted Jun 1, 2016 by Dr. Winston O'Boogie
Posted May 19, 2016 by Rob Kirchgassner
Posted May 23, 2016 by Jonathan Campbell
Posted May 16, 2016 by Jonathan Campbell
Posted May 31, 2016 by Roland Thompson
Posted May 9, 2016 by Jonathan Campbell
Posted May 18, 2016 by Steven Birkner
Posted May 31, 2016 by Fear Fan
Posted May 31, 2016 by Cecil Trachenburg
Posted Apr 19, 2016 by Rob Kirchgassner
Posted May 21, 2016 by Thomas Stockel
Posted May 16, 2016 by Joey Tedesco
Posted May 23, 2016 by Cecil Trachenburg
Posted Apr 18, 2016 by Unusual Suspect
Posted Apr 26, 2016 by Joey Tedesco
Posted May 16, 2016 by Sursum Ursa
Posted Apr 26, 2016 by Thomas Stockel
About the Site:
Text Archives:
Video Archives:
Other Content:
Series Pages:
Feeds (RSS):
Our Patrons:
Video Shows:
Support the Site:
On Other Sites:
Top #tags:

All articles posted to the agony booth are the sole property of the author(s). Please do not copy/reproduce entire articles without permission. Screencaps from movies and TV shows are used for non-profit, fair use purposes of parody and commentary. Star Trek and all related images and trademarks are the property of CBS Studios, Inc.

Reviewer icon artwork provided by Tai Porto, Aaron “McKnackus” Rivera, and Magdalen O’Reilly.